Now, let’s
have a complicated start. I write primarily about Prague Counterpoint here, because this one was available for my Kindle.
Vienna Prelude, the first book of the
Zion Covenant series is available for Kindle in the US and the UK, but the
German amazon only had the paperback edition and not the ebook. So, while I was
waiting for the first of the series, I peeked into Prague Counterpoint and later found myself on the bed, reading and
reading until I finished book 2. By now, I have read halfway through the first
book of the series, too, and I also have read the first pages of book 3 (Munich
Signature). I am not paid for this, nevertheless, something positive
is to follow. :-)
Originally
I got the suggestion for the books of the Zion Covenant series from Anastasia
Vitsky. Since I enjoy reading her reviews and know she has an eye for the important
bits, I thought I’d give the Zion Covenant books a try. I did not regret that I
did, and I say that even though the historic topic covered in Prague Counterpoint is not exactly mine.
The plot of
the series starts in 1936, in the early years of the Third Reich, and you can
follow the development in Germany and her neighbours primarily through the eyes
of two jewish women, musicians, and an American journalist. You see with a lot
of detail, how the jewish people are degraded and humiliated systematically and
continuously, how racial hatred takes over and only the basest instincts and
immoral behavior rules and how jewish people suffer because of this.
The
historic background must have been researched in great detail and it sounded
convincing and accurate to me. I remembered some of German history under the
Nazi regime from school and found all that in the books, too. Some of the historic
descriptions went into greater detail than I would have cared for, but leaving them
out would not always have been easy either, because the historic events are
intermingled with the plot. I think this is a matter of personal preference and
it did not reduce the positive reading experience for me.
What I
found absolutely well done, is how in many scenes the main characters are
tossed around, often victim-like helpless, unable to change much, unable to
influence major parts of their own or their loved ones’ fates. There were some
cruel scenes, though they were by far not as cruel and horrid as they could
have been. But for me, they were more than enough. I could virtually feel how
helpless and humiliated the characters must have felt. Their suffering is
described in a convincing way, at least for me. And even against all odds,
these characters go on. While reading I felt several times how they drew me
with them and I felt as lost as they must have. They do not give up, nor do
they find ways easily to solve the problems they have to face. Their sorrows
are heartbreaking and touching and in a way, how they cope is one of the
reasons why you want to read on.
If you are
looking for a fully fledged love-story, you will be disappointed. This is a
family and friends drama with a little bit of a clean love-story included. The
characters often enough act out of love and out of a selfless sense of responsibility
and there are romantic moments, thought they are few. The lovers in the book
have problems, too and don’t find to each other easily, but the interpersonal
problems of them appear actually rather small, compared to those they have to
face just because they are in the wrong city in the wrong moment. Sometimes it
reminded me of a ship that is lost in a severe storm and can only move to and
fro helplessly, as the wind dictates. Still, this is not a negative point,
because it fits well into the plot. The historical development is interwoven
with it and all in all, this combination with characters who have to face
enormous problems, a believable plot and the historic background of a cruel
time, definitely made it a good read for me.
Who is
meant to read the Zion Covenant series? I assume that the Zion Covenant series
is meant to be read by youths and young adults, starting around the age
of not younger than 15. The assumption is based on the level of understanding
you need to see the immoral and cruel behavior of people in the book, to
understand the systematic reduction of rights for jewish people and to
understand the implications of it all. The book has a section with questions
which help to understand what was read before. This is pretty helpful for
younger readers and readers without any background knowledge. The language that
The Thoenes use in all three books I know about, is very clear, as are the
descriptions. The language is also very easy to understand, which I think I am
allowed to say as a non-native English-speaker. But that does not mean that you
can only enjoy this book at that age.
All in all
I found this a very captivating read and not at all boring. Prague Counterpoint surely is not a
difficult book, and in the past I have stopped reading books by other authors
because the plot was too obvious, combined with a too basic language, even for
me. But Prague Counterpoint is
different. The characters move through the historical events in a way that you
want to know what is going to happen next. And for me, it was not clear if they’d
survive all this or not. Therefore, even though the appropriate age of when to
start reading the Zion Covenant might be 15 and up, I could not see that it
would be boring for adults. I am 35 and enjoyed reading it. … I might even
smuggle my kindle into the labour ward, if the latter books of the series are as
good as the first three. :D (=clear recommendation)
This entry is scheduled for 18th July, 2.00 AM Pacific Daylight Time. I hope it works
I hope you all have a nice and wonderful weekend !